Why Did 'Star Trek' and 'Buffy's Musical Episodes Work, but 'Grey's Anatomy' Didn't?

South Africa News News

Why Did 'Star Trek' and 'Buffy's Musical Episodes Work, but 'Grey's Anatomy' Didn't?
South Africa Latest News,South Africa Headlines
  • 📰 Collider
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 70 sec. here
  • 3 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 31%
  • Publisher: 98%

'Grey's Anatomy' missed all of the best parts.

The Big Picture Musical episodes are always a bit of a risk — they can either go down in television history or flop so badly that they remain the butt of the joke for decades to come. Of the greats is Buffy the Vampire Slayer's "Once More With Feeling," a well-executed and perfectly plotted episode that has set the bar for musical episodes in the two decades since.

In Buffy and Strange New Worlds, as a contrast, the characters' singing is introduced with a cleverly written 'Why Am I Singing' number. The shows immediately acknowledge the strangeness of a musical episode — the characters think it's strange too! This self-awareness is key, a necessary step to get the audience to suspend their realities and buy into one with background music, perfect harmonies, and well-rehearsed dance numbers.

In 'Buffy' and 'Strange New Worlds,' Original Songs Make All The Difference This detachment, which is one of the largest reasons why "Song Beneath the Song" doesn't work, could also be caused by the specific song choices each show made. Both Buffy and Strange New Worlds created their own original songs, while Grey's used only covers. This difference between them is hugely important.

Balancing the Darkness Is Key in a Musical Episode All three of these episodes handle dark subject matter, which may not be the first thing that comes to mind when thinking, hey, let's make a musical. Buffy is reeling after dying, reaching heaven, and being tugged back to reality – her friends thought they brought her back from hell, but they were wrong. On Grey's, which is known for killing off its main characters, Callie is fighting for her life as well as the one of her unborn child.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

Collider /  🏆 1. in US

South Africa Latest News, South Africa Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Why Jenna Dewan Isn't Ready for Daughter Everly's Teenage YearsWhy Jenna Dewan Isn't Ready for Daughter Everly's Teenage YearsJenna Dewan is soaking up all the 'sweet' moments with daughter Everly before she hits her teen years.
Read more »

Michael Worley: Why Celeste Maloy is the ideal pick for Utah’s 2nd DistrictMichael Worley: Why Celeste Maloy is the ideal pick for Utah’s 2nd DistrictMichael Worley: 'For Utah to have the opportunity to send an honest woman to Congress with no previous political ambition is a gift, not just to Utah, but to the nation.'
Read more »

Why some parents wait until their kids graduate high school to divorceWhy some parents wait until their kids graduate high school to divorce'I muttered to myself that as soon as my daughter turned 18, I would be free,' one dad says.
Read more »

Why 'Winter Kills' Is the Perfect Conspiracy Thriller for the QAnon EraWhy 'Winter Kills' Is the Perfect Conspiracy Thriller for the QAnon EraThanks to Quentin Tarantino, 'Winter Kills' - the batshit 1979 movie about Jeff Bridges investigating a JFK-like assassination plot - returns to theaters. Its timing is perfect
Read more »

If inflation is easing, why are gas and groceries still so expensive?If inflation is easing, why are gas and groceries still so expensive?After spiking to the highest level in 40 years, inflation has eased a lot. But that doesn’t mean prices are returning to pre-pandemic levels. To break it down, here are six items that have been through the ups and downs of pandemic-era inflation.
Read more »

'No place to live': Why rebuilding Maui won't be easy after deadly fires'No place to live': Why rebuilding Maui won't be easy after deadly firesWith Maui's wildfires largely contained, island residents are starting to comprehend the economic and housing challenges that lie ahead.
Read more »



Render Time: 2025-02-28 06:38:26