Was This Reddit MIL's Emotional Reaction Over a Baby-Naming Tradition Actually — Gasp — Justified?

South Africa News News

Was This Reddit MIL's Emotional Reaction Over a Baby-Naming Tradition Actually — Gasp — Justified?
South Africa Latest News,South Africa Headlines
  • 📰 SheKnows
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 67 sec. here
  • 3 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 30%
  • Publisher: 51%

Reddit agrees that everyone in this situation regarding a name reveal could've been handled differently.

“My MIL has a family tradition that dates back many generations, naming the first born Diana if the first born was female and William if it was a male,” the pregnant mom continued. “My husband was not the first born and isn’t named William, so I didn’t think the ‘traditional’ naming would be passed on to us.”

But, everyone knows what happens when you assume! You make an a** out of yourself at the baby shower, apparently. “Little did I know that it would because MILs firstborn died too young to have kids and the naming tradition passed to my husband,” she continued, adding, “I was always hesitant to follow the tradition because I don’t like the names and they are very old and I don’t want my kid to get bullied just because of a dumb ‘tradition.

But the pregnant woman completely overreacted … in front of everybody. “I lost it and yelled at her that I’m not naming my child that and it’s my child not hers my husband says ITA but I think I’m not,” she wrote. “I don’t wanna name my kid some old Victorian name just because someone died, [since] the fight my MIL has tried to reach out to me but I don’t wanna talk to her so AITA?”

If you got lost in that slightly confusing rant, I’ll clear it up for you a little: the MIL was feeling nostalgic and sentimental about welcoming a new baby girl in her life after losing her own daughter too young, and her pregnant daughter-in-law yelled at her in front of everyone — in her own home.

Although, to be fair, the MIL should definitely not have tried saying this new baby was her daughter come back to life, nor should she have insisted on the name tradition.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

SheKnows /  🏆 558. in US

South Africa Latest News, South Africa Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Reddit outraged after professor fired for showing images of Muhammad: ‘She did nothing wrong’Reddit outraged after professor fired for showing images of Muhammad: ‘She did nothing wrong’Reddit users defended a professor after she was fired for showing images of Muhammad in an Islamic art class, despite reportedly warning students multiple times.
Read more »

r/askscience - AskScience AMA Series: We're scientists and engineers on the InSight lander team who studied the deep interior of Mars. Ask us anything!r/askscience - AskScience AMA Series: We're scientists and engineers on the InSight lander team who studied the deep interior of Mars. Ask us anything!What would you ask the team behind our NASAInSight Mars lander? We're answering your questions now in our Reddit AMA ('Ask Me Anything')—join us as we celebrate InSight's completed four-year mission, and look ahead at what's to come from all the data:
Read more »

Two Co-Parents Are At Odds About When Kids Should Be Allowed To Order Adult Meals At RestaurantsTwo Co-Parents Are At Odds About When Kids Should Be Allowed To Order Adult Meals At RestaurantsA dad turned to Reddit to ask if he should be curbing his son's food intake after his ex-wife called him out multiple times for giving them too much food.
Read more »



Render Time: 2025-03-04 13:43:01