The question to be asked was: would a rational person find a link between banning cigarettes and reducing the spread of the virus and the number of people who would die of the virus?
In its application papers, Fita argued that the court erred in applying the rationality test that imposing the ban on tobacco products was rationally linked to the purpose of the gazetted regulations in terms of section 27 of the Disaster Management Act.According to the South African Drug Policy Initiative , the court’s basis of legal rationality is a “narrowly defined minimum threshold” for government’s decision-making.
“Before implementing any public health policies, the authorities are obliged to consider both the potential benefits versus the countervailing risks and costs of those policies. Fita’s medical experts pointed out that neither of these assessments was carried out and provided evidence to show how the harms and costs of the banning far outweighed any of its purported benefits.
But it was not for the court to decide whether the smoking policy was good or bad, but instead to apply the rationality test, said De Vos.
South Africa Latest News, South Africa Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Not even Covid-19 can thwart the black funeralThe act of paying the 'last respect' leads us to even disrespect and disregard the laws, and sadly it looks like the extravagance and cost associated with black funerals are going nowhere.
Read more »
Walks in parks are OK, but not going to the beach, Dlamini-Zuma confirmsThe curfew from 9pm to 4am was a result of Cabinet noting that the virus was spread by people and to ensure that movement of people was reduced, a curfew was a viable solution.
Read more »
SA on Ramaphosa's booze news: 'Haai, not even a warning to get stock'Seriously, no booze from tonight. Soz.
Read more »
Mark Boucher not convinced the West Indies tour is going to take placeProteas team director Mark Boucher is not convinced that the West Indies tour that is scheduled for the end of this month is going to take place.
Read more »
Upgrades did not show their worth, says Ferrari's BinottoFerrari fast-tracked performance upgrades through to the second race of the Formula One season in Austria but unhappy team boss Mattia Binotto said on Saturday they had not delivered as planned
Read more »
Smaller creditors not happy as vote on SAA rescue deal loomsA 75% vote in favour of the business rescue plan will be enough to pass it. Bigger creditors, such as the banks, hold the majority of the voting rights and if they all vote in favour of the plan, it should pass.
Read more »