Race can be a predictor of disadvantage but cannot serve as a proxy for disadvantage
federal executive chair Helen Zille by saying: “The debate on whether race is a proxy or not for disadvantage in the DA is sadly back. Nevertheless it must be addressed. The simple answer is yes, of course race is a proxy for disadvantage.”
This doublethink is common, but groundless. While race can be a predictor of disadvantage in SA it can certainly not serve as a proxy for disadvantage. Being black does not automatically mean being disadvantaged. Is someone like Proteas bowler Kagiso Rabada, the son of a doctor and a lawyer, who attended St Stithians, disadvantaged? The answer is clearly no.
While we accept that the Rabadas of SA are still fairly rare and the vast majority of poor people are black, it is also true that some white people have been left behind, even if on a vanishingly smaller scale than black South Africans. But is it right to consider Mamphela Ramphele disadvantaged but not a white school dropout living in a squatter camp on the West Rand?
Why not pivot empowerment policy so that it benefits people who are actually disadvantaged, rather than simply focusing on race, which has been SA’s curse for so long? An alternative has been developed by my colleague, Anthea Jeffery; her economic empowerment for the disadvantaged model focuses directly on disadvantage without having to refer to race at all.
If the current way of doing things was working, we would not have a real unemployment rate nudging 40%. Send us an e-mail with your comments. Letters of more than 300 words will be edited for length. Send your letter by
South Africa Latest News, South Africa Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
LETTER: Vaal pollutionThe noxious cocktail of Incompetent officials and corruption that caused the problem must be addressed
Read more »
LETTER: Job suspension with full pay or no pay?Constitutional Court rules that precautionary suspension on full pay can take place without discussion
Read more »
DA sends open letter to Ndlozi on his Twitter comments against Springboks - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports, world, business, sport coverage of all South African current events. Africa's news leader.The DA's provincial leader in the North West Joe McGluwa has penned an open letter to EFF spokesperson Mbuyiseni Ndlozi over his messages on social media following the Springboks victory at the Rugby World Cup.
Read more »
Holiday in the WildI loved this movie because it reignited my adoration for all things wild and opened my eyes to the importance of the conservation of wild animals and their habitat.
Read more »
Education MEC's 'faulty Merc' scam costs taxpayer R100k a monthA KwaZulu-Natal MEC has been caught using an elaborate scam to justify his not using the state car used by his predecessor - instead blowing hundreds of thousands of rands in taxpayers' money on car hire.
Read more »
LETTER: Job suspension with full pay or no pay?Constitutional Court rules that precautionary suspension on full pay can take place without discussion
Read more »