Joining the Dots: Pravin Gordhan, Floyd Shivambu and the dodgy origins of the ‘Indian cabal’ narrative

South Africa News News

Joining the Dots: Pravin Gordhan, Floyd Shivambu and the dodgy origins of the ‘Indian cabal’ narrative
South Africa Latest News,South Africa Headlines
  • 📰 dailymaverick
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 74 sec. here
  • 3 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 33%
  • Publisher: 84%

In April 2017, Pravin Gordhan addressed a packed audience in St George’s Cathedral in Cape Town, a week after President Jacob Zuma had fired him as finance minister, a move that signalled South Africa had been well and truly captured. Gordhan urged the crowd not to give up hope and to ‘join the dots’ in understanding what was taking place.

He became a moral authority to many – and the object of a concerted smear campaign. In this unauthorised biography, Jonathan Ancer and Chris Whitfield take a magnifying glass to someone at the centre of South Africa’s most tumultuous period and try to understand the man behind the public image.

But his real target was Pravin Gordhan, and in that respect Shivambu was anything but nuanced: “The cabal was basically an Indian cabal that was put in place to slander the character and standing of African comrades in the MDM, and it was led by Pravin Gordhan,” said the EFF’s number two.

It’s unclear who authored this supposed report, dated 14 March 1990, and the copy in the O’Malley Archives ends in the middle of a sentence. The site warns that the document is “incomplete”. This apparently didn’t put Shivambu off his stride and he suggested that “it appears that Mr Maharaj drafted the report”. Maharaj, speaking to the’s Franny Rabkin in March 2019, said he had “no knowledge of, or participation in, the preparation of this so-called report”.

Kumi Naidoo, a Durban-born human-rights activist who gained international renown as the executive director of Greenpeace, wrote his doctoral thesis at the University of Oxford on Indian political resistance in Durban between 1979 and 1996. In it he teases out the origins of the cabal allegations.) and UDF politics over issues such as boycotts and the relationship with the tricameral Parliament, and says that these tensions manifested themselves in different ways at the local level.

He points out that five Chatsworth branches and the one Phoenix branch were part of the ANC’s first regional conference in 1991, “when four Indians were elected to serve on the regional executive committee”.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

dailymaverick /  🏆 3. in ZA

South Africa Latest News, South Africa Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Pravin Gordhan to retire after electionsPravin Gordhan to retire after electionsPravin Gordhan to retire after elections
Read more »

Pravin Gordhan announces retirement from active politics - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports,Pravin Gordhan announces retirement from active politics - SABC News - Breaking news, special reports,Pravin Gordhan will resign from active politics following the general election in May.
Read more »

Pravin Gordhan announces retirementPravin Gordhan announces retirementGordhan’s 30-year political career has been marked by his stance on transparency but he has been accused of leaving state-owned enterprises “chronically depende
Read more »

Good riddance: EFF welcomes ‘fraud’ Pravin Gordhan’s retirementGood riddance: EFF welcomes ‘fraud’ Pravin Gordhan’s retirementThe EFF Pravin Gordhan's retirement comes after he left a trail of destruction in the country's strategic State-owned companies.
Read more »

Pravin Gordhan wants ‘smooth transition’ as he retires from politicsPravin Gordhan wants ‘smooth transition’ as he retires from politicsProfessor Andre Duvenhage from the North West University (NWU) said he does not believe that Gordhan will be missed.
Read more »



Render Time: 2025-02-16 06:52:03